I think that a lot of times, girls tend to be attracted to men that in ways remind them of dad (or another important man to them growing up). I don't mind jeans and flannels...mostly what mine lives in and what I grew up in my dad. I do find a man in a suit pretty hot. I just didn't grow up in the country and when I picture that, what comes into my head is conservative bible belt. And I don't like country music. I grew up with rock and some pop. I was kind of looking for someone a lot like my daddy except much more of a bookworm/intellectual. My dad didn't fish or hunt or even watch sports....he liked music (now Dad thinks he's a little monster) and liked tech toys. I'm 32 and have a VCR my whole life, CD's and DVD's when they were really new, dad had an atari when I was very little and a video camera (my life is on film), and a computer since I was in grade school (OMG was that computer expensive and so primitive to what we have now). Dad got an iPod and cell phone before most people had them....I'm just shocked he hasn't talked mom into an iPad yet.
I have never been an ATV or snowmobile. Dh has but that was before we met. We would be much more likely to go to a museum or see a musical. I have been on a horse before but have never been up close to a cow....and I live in the dairy state!
As far as fixing stuff....one reason we built a house was to avoid having to fix stuff up right away. OMG it was such a procedure with the two of us just to change the oil in our new snow blower....took over an hour and that was with instruction books. Getting the pilot light going in the fireplace was like a 30 minute ordeal.
I would never call him a guy guy.

He likes football and baseball....but yeah when we moved here and all his coworkers were talking about hunting and where he hunted....his response was the grocery store.
I was really snobby when I was looking for dates 13 years ago. I wouldn't have gone out with a guy who wasn't in college or hadn't graduated from college...not a tech school either but had to be a traditional bachelors. I would not go with a republican at all and I wouldn't have dated a religious guy. Oh and I couldn't have dated someone military or a hunter since I cannot stand guns. My other biggie was he couldn't be homophobic. It's amazing I ever got married!

I really had pictured myself back than eventually married to a professor. And he did consider that but didn't really enjoy being a teaching assistant much. And I'm good with him working in manufacturing now...he doesn't use his degrees but I still like knowing he has them. And that I could say (and have), let's both read Plato's Republic or some Neitzsche and talk about it....and we both find it fun.
It would be handy though to have someone who knew how to fix things or didn't complain the whole time when we have yet another piece of furniture to put together!