
Originally Posted by
stash
Right, and I'm not against telling Oscar what other people believe. But I think there's a rational, appropriate age to tell him those things. To do so too early is potentially planting inappropriate seeds and inadvertently swaying his beliefs one way or another. At the age of three, or four, a child is impressionable beyond belief. You want to give him loads of abstract what-ifs when he can barely figure out why it rains outside, even with careful explanation?
Give you an aside example. Oscar asks me recently (again) how the baby got in my belly. I tell him (again) that daddy has sperm and mommy has eggs in her belly. That daddy's sperm gets into mommy's belly and when they meet up, a baby "seed" forms, like his sunflower seeds. The seed grows, and if it's a "good seed" it becomes a baby, which it has. Sometimes the seeds don't grow and they just decompose. If it does grow, it keeps growing until the baby is big enough to live on its own. I avoid talking about penises and vaginas, or using the word "death" with the seed, because that's a level of information I don't think he's asking for, and I don't think he needs to really think about yet. I ask him "is that what you were asking sweety, or do you need more information?" And he says "no mom, I get it, thanks." Age appropriate material.
In a similar sense, providing children with the basics of life and death are age appropriate material for 3-4, IMO. Providing them with a world view of spiritual beliefs is not. Yet. It's far more complicated than they are able to reason through yet, and it's not necessary for their current state of education. Why muddy and confuse the already confusing?
When they get older - I can't wait to explain all the different religions, spiritual beliefs, and let Oscar choose (or choose not to seek, which in my personal opinion is the healthiest route). I'll support him no matter which way he goes, though I may not agree with him.